The Extended Cut Of Spider-Man 2 Ruins The Greatest Comic Book Movie Ever Made

Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man trilogy was massively influential on its style, and on blockbuster cinema as a complete. All these years later, within the age of cinematic universes, Spider-Man 2 nonetheless holds up as one of many best comedian guide films ever made, if not the easiest. Tobey Maguire introduced new dimensions to his definitive portrayal of Peter Parker; Alfred Molina’s Doc Ock affords the right steadiness of mustache-twirling villainy and real pathos; set items just like the prepare struggle are nonetheless a spectacle to behold; and Spidey shedding his powers creates an fascinating battle that forces him to confront whether or not he’s emotionally outfitted to tackle his “nice accountability.”

Regardless of critics praising Spider-Man 2 as presumably the best superhero film ever made and one of the most satisfying sequels of all time, Raimi nonetheless felt the necessity to return into the reducing room and re-edit it for a 2007 DVD launch. Dubbed Spider-Man 2.1, the prolonged minimize of Spider-Man 2 makes a bunch of pointless adjustments to an already good film.

RELATED: Tobey Maguire Was (And Still Is) The Best Spider-Man

The prolonged minimize of Spider-Man 2 provides eight minutes to the runtime, comprised of each deleted scenes scooped off the reducing room ground and elongated variations of present scenes. However the enhancing decisions on this new model are actually weird and so they all detract from the tonal steadiness of the film. The brand new scenes are all superfluous and pointless, and decelerate the circulation of the story, like Mary Jane going procuring along with her pals and J. Jonah Jameson dressing up as Spider-Man.

Spidey in an alley in Spider-Man 2

Spider-Man 2.1 spoils two of the film’s funniest moments. The important thing to comedy is timing, and the timing works rather well within the authentic edit of Bruce Campbell’s cameo appearance in Spider-Man 2. He performs an usher on the theater who offers Peter a collection of little ideas to enhance his look, like tying his shoe and adjusting his tie, earlier than lastly denying him entrance into the theater. Spider-Man 2.1 extends this sequence and it goes on for too lengthy for the bit to land as successfully.

The scene within the elevator is one in all Spider-Man 2’s most hilarious moments. Spidey finds himself unable to shoot webs, so his solely method to get all the way down to the bottom is to enter an workplace constructing and take the elevator. A person will get on the elevator and says, “Cool Spidey outfit,” mistaking him for a cosplayer. What makes this scene work so effectively is the understated awkwardness. In Spider-Man 2.1, there’s a totally completely different model of this scene. The man within the elevator as an alternative acknowledges him as the actual Spidey, introduces himself as a PR agent, and randomly begins snapping his fingers and pitching outlandish methods to boost Spidey’s public picture – it’s like watching Michael Scott do improv. This model of the scene is so zany and over-the-top that it performs like a comedic second from a Michael Bay film.

Spidey and a guy on an elevator in Spider-Man 2

When Peter visits the physician’s workplace and makes up a dream about being Spider-Man so he can speak about his insecurities with out giving away his secret identity, the physician tells him he has a option to not be Spider-Man. This scene is a serious emotional catalyst for Peter, however the poignant level of the scene is misplaced within the prolonged minimize as a result of the physician rambles on with an aimless story earlier than lastly attending to the “you’ve got a selection” half.

Spider-Man 2.1 isn’t the one alternate model of Raimi’s Spider-Man films obtainable on the house media market. The “editor’s minimize” of Spider-Man 3 might be present in sure Blu-ray boxsets. This re-edit felt a bit of extra crucial than Spider-Man 2’s, as a result of in contrast to Spider-Man 2, Spider-Man 3 was panned by critics as a deeply flawed film. Bob Murawski’s “editor’s minimize” of Spider-Man 3 doesn’t change as a lot as followers would possibly hope – it nonetheless has that notorious “Dig on this” scene within the jazz membership – nevertheless it does decrease Venom’s controversial position and features a few new scenes to deepen Peter and the Sandman’s arcs. It made far more sense to change Spider-Man 3 than Spider-Man 2, as a result of there was room for enchancment in Spider-Man 3.

Spidey and Doc Ock fighting on a train in Spider-Man 2

The lesson here’s a fairly apparent one: re-edits must be reserved for films that weren’t edited proper the primary time. Justice League wanted a model that adheres to Zack Snyder’s imaginative and prescient versus the watered-down studio model that made it into theaters. Spider-Man 3 wanted to be tidied up with some further enhancing, however its predecessor didn’t. The “Special Editions” of the original Star Wars trilogy made it abundantly clear that meddling within the classics is a nasty thought. Spider-Man 2 didn’t want an alternate minimize any greater than The Darkish Knight wants one. If a film connects with audiences and has a profound impact that makes them need to revisit it over and over, go away it alone.

MORE: There’s A (Slightly) Better Version Of Spider-Man 3 Out There

Sam Raimi Made A Weird And Wild Superhero Movie A Decade Before Spider-Man

Before swinging Spider-Man into theaters, Sam Raimi’s original character Darkman smashed box offices and expectations.

Read Next

About The Writer | The Prolonged Reduce Of Spider-Man 2 Ruins The Best Comedian Guide Film Ever Made


Inter Reviewed is an automatic aggregator of the all world’s media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, all materials to their authors. If you are the owner of the content and do not want us to publish your materials, please contact us by email – The content will be deleted within 24 hours.

Related Articles

Back to top button