Simply Red is the wild card on this 12 months’s Obama summer playlist. You count on the previous president’s curated playlists to be loaded with impeccably hip picks, from all around the worlds of pop, soul, jazz, rock & roll, and his 2021 Summer season Playlist isn’t any exception. He’s received classic classics like Ella Fitzgerald and Louis Armstrong, he’s received cool children like Jazmine Sullivan and Migos and Wye Oak. Status grooves, all the best way. However then proper there close to the highest, protruding like a sore thumb, precisely one Eighties crying-mom basic: Merely Crimson’s 1986 mall-pop ballad “Holding Again the Years.”
What does it imply in 2021 for Merely Crimson to grow to be the type of cultural artifact that America’s main statesman can level to with pleasure and designate as a theme tune for this land of ours, in these troubled instances? “Holding Again the Years” certain doesn’t slot in with the remainder of the glamorous playlist. But there’s one thing simple about this tune. A depressing Eighties ballad about waking up and shaking off years of day by day trauma? For some unusual purpose, that seems like a nationwide anthem.
First issues first: in case you don’t acknowledge the tune, it’s in all probability since you assume the title is “I’ll Maintain Holding On.” However you undoubtedly know this tune. “Holding Again the Years” comes from the U.Okay. group Merely Crimson. Mick Hucknall was a red-headed, pasty-faced Manchester child who got here out of the punk scene: as everyone discovered from 24 Hour Occasion Individuals, he was there for the notorious 1977 Intercourse Pistols gig, attended by each future rock legend on the town (and no person else). However his coronary heart belonged to American R&B, and Merely Crimson hit Quantity One in the summertime of 1986 with “Holding Again the Years.”
Merely Crimson was simply one in all a passel of mid-Eighties lounge-soul balladeers to emerge from the U.Okay., rising from the postpunk doldrums. Sade, the Model Council, Every part however the Lady, my beloved Blow Monkeys: depressive music for depressive instances. Merely Crimson’s first High 40 hit was explicitly concerning the mass unemployment of the Reagan-Thatcher years: a canopy of the Valentine Bros.’ 1982 R&B single “Cash’s Too Tight (to Point out).” However “Holding Again the Years” is about an emotional wasteland. Hucknall sings about what a depressing mess his life has been, ever since childhood. However the refrain is one line he repeats, again and again: “I’ll maintain holding on.”
It’s a tune about understanding it’s time to maneuver on, however refusing to let go of a no-win state of affairs, resigning your self to extra of the identical. There’s no climax, no catchy hook, only one heartache after one other. One thing about this tune spoke to folks. Your mother in all probability thought it was by Carly Simon. (A number of folks did.) However it was soulful sufficient for the Isley Brothers to cowl.
“Holding Again the Years” summed up a state of emotional stagnation, at a time of cultural stagnation. America was overdosing on dreariness in 1986, the 12 months Huey Lewis scored a success tune informing us it’s “Hip to Be Sq..” The 12 months Jermaine Stewart sang, “We Don’t Should Take Our Garments Off (to Have a Good Time).” The 12 months folks gladly paid cash to see High Gun. Bear in mind the High Gun opening scene, with the phrases: “Indian Ocean. Current Day”? That’s how the 12 months felt: It was at all times going to be Current Day. This was a everlasting situation — the Reagan-Thatcher period had worn out all potentialities for a future. Because the famous historian William Joel has put it, this was the winter of “AIDS, crack, Bernie Goetz.”
“Holding Again the Years” didn’t recommend any type of resolution to this malaise: it simply summed up the sensation truthfully. It had the same vibe to an earlier 1986 Quantity One hit, Madonna’s “Stay to Inform.” Each Mick and Madonna have a tragic story to inform. They’ve gotten burned earlier than by hoping issues would change, however they’re not giving up hope. They’re decided to maintain that bitter depressing reminiscence alive simply because that feeling — this actually occurred, it’s not simply in my head — that’s what retains them feeling alive. Like Madonna, Mick simply desires to dwell to inform.
“Holding Again the Years” had a slow-burning reign on the radio, topping the charts proper in between Billy Ocean and Genesis. It was additionally the summer season of the Smiths’ The Queen Is Lifeless, which articulated the identical Northern English melancholy: the entire vibe of “while you wish to dwell, the place you begin, the place do you go?” It hits house within the wreckage of 2021, after we’re recovering from years of political trauma, after we’re speculated to be thrilled it’s been six entire months because the final presidentially accredited terrorist assault on the Capitol.
Merely Crimson’s greatest got here a 12 months later, in the summertime of 1987: “The Proper Factor,” one of many period’s best songs concerning the timeless matter of studying how you can give oral intercourse, “on the job,” because it have been. Mick tries his damnedest, whereas the backup singers urge, “Get off your again, boy! Get on monitor, boy!” (The Eighties have been such a hotbed of emotionally evocative oral intercourse songs, from varied views, however that’s a subject for an additional day.)
However it wasn’t as large as “Holding Again the Years” — folks simply preferred Mick so much higher when he was struggling. Merely Crimson fluked into one other Quantity One in 1989, a canopy of “If You Don’t Know Me by Now” — think about having the gall to remake a Teddy Pendergrass ballad, then think about being English. The world determined to overlook this atrocity ever occurred, and the world received that one proper.
“Holding Again the Years” is the quintessential 1986 tune, nevertheless it’s by no means pale away. As Stereogum’s Tom Breihan recently noted, the tune had an afterlife in hip-hop, getting sampled by Masta P in his 1996 No Restrict basic “The Ghetto Gained’t Change” and Model Nubian in “Maintain On.”
And this tune about summer-’86 stagnation works superbly as a soundtrack to summer-’21 stagnation. That’s why “Holding Again the Years” lives on. Typically it’s comforting to listen to a singer who isn’t promising and even planning to make it higher. Typically you simply wish to hear him maintain on to that distress. Effectively performed, Mr. President.