Red Dead Redemption 3’s Most Interesting Time Period May Be Obvious

The Crimson Lifeless Redemption video games could star gunslingers, however each happen lengthy after the golden age of outlaws. The primary recreation is about primarily in 1911, a daring selection by Rockstar that borders on deliberately anachronistic. Even Crimson Lifeless 2’s primary plot, set in 1899, explores a world the place gangs like Dutch’s are already relics of a bygone period, the topic of biographies, campfire songs, and collectable playing cards. The gang is caught up to now, whereas their enemies – whether or not they’re the Pinkertons or the Italian mob – have a noticeably Twentieth-century really feel. Crimson Lifeless Redemption 3 might want to discover a option to discover the collection’ primary themes from a special approach.

After the primary recreation launched, many Crimson Lifeless followers hoped to see a sequel starring Jack Marston, John’s son. Whereas there are arguments towards making Jack the primary player character within the subsequent recreation, there are additionally causes that setting Red Dead Redemption 3 throughout Jack’s maturity might ship a novel expertise that takes a few of Crimson Lifeless’s main themes to their pure conclusions.

RELATED: Red Dead Redemption 2 Player Modifies Desk to ‘Feel’ Horseback Riding

Crimson Lifeless 1 And The Loss of life Of The Outlaw

John Marston stands off against an army.

In Crimson Lifeless Redemption 1 John Marston is a former outlaw who’s now utterly topic to the federal oversight that the Previous West famously lacked. He could also be on horseback below the sprawling western sky, however John is something however free.

After John’s wife Abigail and son Jack are taken by the Bureau of Investigation, he’s given no selection however to search out his former comrades on the federal government’s behalf. To the extent that John is an outlaw in any respect within the first recreation, he’s one who has misplaced all pretense of freedom.

The message is evident – by the point Red Dead 1 is about, the Previous West is useless. The Bureau forcing John to kill his former mates is virtually home cleansing. The federal government is highly effective sufficient not solely to wipe out the final remnants of the golden age of outlaws, however to have the issue resolve itself.

Crimson Lifeless 2 And The Loss of life Of Nostalgia

arthur morgan john marston goodbye red dead redemption 2

A part of the genius of Crimson Lifeless Redemption 2 is that, regardless of being a prequel, the scenario the Van der Linde gang finds itself in isn’t too far faraway from John’s within the first recreation. The sport begins with the gang escaping the fallout of the failed Blackwater ferry heist, the occasion which kicks off their spiraling decline. Though there are spots of hope, on reflection it’s clear that your complete plot takes place throughout the gang’s demise rattles, and their flailing makes an attempt to get again on high solely solidify their destiny.

From the angle of Crimson Lifeless 1, Red Dead 2’s story appears just like the gang in it is prime. They could be doomed, however in contrast to John’s story within the first recreation there’s nonetheless some pretense of freedom. The second recreation nearly means that if the collection have been to proceed to go backward in time the primary characters would nonetheless discover themselves fighting the perceived decline of their lifestyle.

Crimson Lifeless 2 means that the golden age the Van der Linde gang strives to emulate would possibly by no means have existed in any respect exterior of Dutch’s romantic notions. The unique Crimson Lifeless makes it clear that its characters don’t have a future. What the second recreation subtly suggests, nonetheless, is that they by no means actually had a lot of a previous.

RELATED: Red Dead Redemption 2 Player Creates Peaky Blinders Version of Arthur Morgan

Crimson Lifeless 3 And The Loss of life Of The Western

Jack Marston RDR 1 epilogue

The collection’ exploration of nostalgia may very well be an argument to set Crimson Lifeless 3 earlier than Crimson Lifeless 2. One other prequel might present how even the gang’s greatest days noticed them struggling to maintain one step forward of the legislation, and that they solely ever actually appeared like the nice previous days in gentle of the gang’s whole collapse on the flip of the century. If Crimson Lifeless 3 goes to comprehend the complete potential of the collection’ themes, nonetheless, it ought to discover what occurred to Jack Marston after the occasions of the primary recreation.

A Crimson Lifeless recreation set in Jack’s younger maturity would stretch Crimson Lifeless’s exploration of nostalgia to its absolute breaking level. Though Crimson Lifeless 1 was already extraordinarily late for a Western, if there’s one factor the primary two video games make completely clear, it’s that irrespective of how onerous its characters battle, time strikes on. Dutch van der Linde’s ultimate speech sums it up completely – “we are able to’t battle change. Can’t battle gravity. We are able to’t battle nothing.”

The subsequent recreation shouldn’t take refuge up to now, because it ought to as an alternative discover how Jack’s failure to let the previous go might doom his future. Crimson Lifeless Redemption 1 ends in an act of revenge, with Jack taking pictures Edgar Ross, the Bureau agent who arrange his father. John may need grown up in a world the place a person might cross state traces to keep away from a homicide cost, but it surely’s clear that’s not the world his son lives in.

A Crimson Lifeless 3 story set shortly after the events of Red Dead 1 would pose one main query – can Jack let go of the previous, or will he doom himself by repeating it? It’s a narrative that may doubtless both finish in Jack’s demise or true redemption, escaping his attachment to the outlaw way of life as an alternative of dying with it. It might discover whether or not Jack, like Dutch, is unable to withstand preventing a shedding battle towards time, or whether or not or not Crimson Lifeless’s final outlaw can embrace the altering world round him with out being destroyed by it.

John and Arthur may need misplaced their battle towards altering instances, however in addition they died – they by no means needed to face the futures they feared. As Crimson Lifeless’s sole surviving player character, Jack does. Exploring what it means for Jack Marston to stay the lifetime of a Western gunslinger after his father’s demise may very well be the right conclusion to a Crimson Lifeless trilogy, exploring not solely how males like John and Arthur have been chewed up by altering instances, but in addition how males like Jack would possibly escape the identical destiny.

Crimson Lifeless Redemption 3 isn’t confirmed to be in improvement.

MORE: The Red Dead Redemption 2 Characters Based on Real People

Red Dead Redemption 3 Needs to Break a Series Tradition to Stay Unpredictable

Red Dead Redemption 3 would need to break one major franchise tradition, but this could risk undermining a major theme of the games so far.

Read Next

About The Creator | Crimson Lifeless Redemption 3’s Most Fascinating Time Interval Might Be Apparent


TaraSubramaniam is a Interreviewed U.S. News Reporter based in London. His focus is on U.S. politics and the environment. He has covered climate change extensively, as well as healthcare and crime. TaraSubramaniam joined Interreviewed in 2023 from the Daily Express and previously worked for Chemist and Druggist and the Jewish Chronicle. He is a graduate of Cambridge University. Languages: English. You can get in touch with me by emailing:

Related Articles

Back to top button