Parents Sue After Daughter’s 20-Stab-Wound Death Ruled Suicide by Medical Examiner: Outrage

A ten-year journey to seek out the reality will lastly transfer ahead for the mother and father of a girl they consider was murdered and whose demise they are saying was wrongly dominated a suicide.

Ellen Greenberg died in January 2011. When she was discovered lifeless in her condominium, the 27-year-old trainer had 20 stab wounds. The health worker, after wavering, dominated her demise a suicide.

Her mother and father have refused to simply accept that as the reality and now have been allowed a non-jury trial after they sued the coroner’s workplace, in accordance with KYW-TV.

“We stay up for the trial in hopes of acquiring justice for Ellen,” Sandra Greenberg, Ellen’s mom, stated.

Health worker Marlon Osbourne at one level issued a preliminary ruling that her demise was a murder, then issued a closing ruling of suicide.


Watch: Biden Tries to Explain Driving Cross-Country in an Electric Car, It Goes Horribly Wrong

As recounted by The Washington Post, the case lacked a lot in the best way of evidence that anybody else however Ellen Greenberg had been within the condominium. Entry was both by the balcony or entrance door. The door was barred from the within and there have been no contemporary footprints within the snow of the balcony. There have been no indicators of theft.

Probably the most telling objects was that she had no defensive wounds, and there was solely her DNA discovered on the knife and her garments. She had been seeing a psychiatrist, and suicide ideation was a facet impact of the medicines she was taking.

However the household by no means believed the March 2011 ruling that their daughter killed herself as a result of she was glad in her life.

“It is mindless,” stated the Greenbergs’ legal professional, Joseph Podraza, who added the 10-year battle has been motivated by the mother and father’ love for his or her daughter.

“They need to know what occurred to their daughter,” he stated.

Nevertheless, Ellen Berkowitz, town’s lawyer, stated there isn’t any authorized option to do what the mother and father need.

“They basically ask this Court docket to sit down as a sur-medical examiner, to overrule the dedication of the medical skilled vested by state legislation and the Philadelphia Code with the only real duty and discretion to find out the trigger and method of demise,” Berkowitz wrote in a courtroom submitting.

However the household has raised questions. On the day she died, Ellen Greenberg stuffed up her fuel tank on her means dwelling from work. There was no notice.

On the day she died, {a partially} eaten fruit salad was discovered within the kitchen close to her physique.


Mass Murder: Teen Kills Girl and Her Parents After Being Caught in Her Bedroom

Podraza has argued in courtroom that the knife block within the kitchen was on its facet, claiming it could possibly be an indication of a battle. There was a big gash on the again of her head, which he has argued could possibly be an indication she was hit from behind, and will clarify why she didn’t attempt to defend herself.

“We now know, so far as I’m involved, that this was not a suicide,” he instructed the Put up.

Town has argued that the ruling isn’t a bar to an investigation if there’s something to analyze.

“The health worker’s dedication is binding on nobody … If a prosecuting authority have been satisfied that Ellen Greenberg was murdered, there isn’t any statute of limitations on murder they usually may pursue it,” town stated.

Podraza stated Greenberg’s mother and father desire a “forthright, full investigation.”

Their goal, now, although, is to reply the query Podraza posed: “Is that this a suicide, or is that this one thing else?” | Mother and father Sue After Daughter’s 20-Stab-Wound Dying Dominated Suicide by Medical Examiner: Outrage

Huynh Nguyen

Inter Reviewed is an automatic aggregator of the all world’s media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, all materials to their authors. If you are the owner of the content and do not want us to publish your materials, please contact us by email – The content will be deleted within 24 hours.

Related Articles

Back to top button