Opinion: Slower S&P 500 earnings growth is not bullish — no matter what some stock market ‘experts’ are saying

Some exuberant analysts are attempting to place a bullish spin on the dramatic slowing within the S&P 500’s earnings per share progress price projected for the following a number of quarters. They’re mistaken .

The desk under summarizes the S&P 500’s

trailing 12-month as-reported EPS progress charges, based mostly on estimates from Customary & Poor’s. Discover that the year-over-year progress price on the finish of 2022 is projected to be about one-eighth of what it was on this yr’s third quarter. Furthermore, earnings projections usually are overly optimistic.

Quarter ending

Yr-over-year change in trailing 12-month EPS 

Sep. 30, 2021


Dec. 31, 2021


Mar. 31, 2022


Jun. 30, 2022


Sep. 30, 2022


Dec. 31, 2022


Since 1927, as many on social media have been mentioning, the S&P 500 has turned in its greatest returns, on common, throughout quarters during which the year-over-year change in EPS was adverse — between 25% decrease and 10% decrease, the truth is. The S&P 500’s annualized return throughout such quarters was 26.7%, in keeping with Ned Davis Analysis, versus a mean achieve of two.4% throughout quarters during which the S&P 500’s year-over-year price over change was larger than 20%.

The issue with this narrative isn’t with the underlying knowledge, which (like the entire knowledge equipped by Ned Davis Analysis) is top-notch. The issue as an alternative is with the interpretation the bulls are placing on the information.

That’s as a result of the Ned Davis knowledge replicate a contemporaneous relationship, correlating the inventory market’s efficiency in a given quarter with EPS progress price over the 12 months as much as and together with that very same quarter. However for the reason that inventory market is ahead trying, its efficiency in a given quarter will to a far larger extent replicate projected earnings progress a number of quarters therefore.

To indicate how ahead trying the inventory market usually is, I calculated the correlation coefficient between the S&P 500’s return in a given quarter and earnings progress charges in subsequent quarters. As you’ll be able to see, the strongest correlation exists with the expansion price three-quarters therefore. (My calculations replicate the market again to 1871, courtesy of information from Yale College’s Robert Shiller.)

Correlation coefficient between S&P 500’s progress price in given quarter and EPS y-o-y progress price in specified quarter

Similar quarter


1 quarter therefore


2 quarters therefore


3 quarters therefore


4 quarters therefore


When specializing in the correlation with the earnings progress price three quarters therefore, the bulls’ “much less is extra” story disappears. For instance, when the year-over-year EPS progress price three quarters therefore is between adverse 10% and adverse 25%, the S&P 500’s common quarterly return is 8.2% annualized. When that progress price is over 20%, the S&P 500’s common return is sort of double — 14.8% annualized.

In different phrases, when measured correctly, quicker earnings progress correlates with greater inventory market returns — simply as you’d anticipate.

Why market forecasting is so troublesome

The correlation coefficients within the above desk are comparatively low. Regardless that the 17% coefficient that exists when specializing in three-quarters therefore is statistically vital, it received’t provide help to a lot to beat the market. This coefficient signifies that subsequent earnings progress explains or predicts solely a small portion of the inventory market’s return.

I devoted a column to this subject this past March, and readers ought to seek the advice of it for a fuller evaluation. Briefly, I reported that you’d have considerably lagged a buy-and-hold technique since 1980 even in case you had been clairvoyant sufficient to know the earnings progress price 12 months into the long run. That’s as a result of modifications within the worth/earnings ratio have had a larger affect on the inventory market’s shorter-term return than the earnings themselves.

The underside line? Whereas there’s something intuitively interesting in regards to the bulls’ narrative about much less being extra, it’s unhelpful and could also be flatly mistaken.

Mark Hulbert is an everyday contributor to MarketWatch. His Hulbert Rankings tracks funding newsletters that pay a flat payment to be audited. He could be reached at mark@hulbertratings.com

Additionally learn: Apple and Amazon are struggling, so investors may want to look to these tech stocks instead

Plus: Market’s ‘golden cross’ is not the heavenly sign for stocks the bulls would have you believe

https://www.marketwatch.com/story/slower-s-p-500-earnings-growth-is-not-bullish-no-matter-what-some-stock-market-experts-are-saying-11635490918?rss=1&siteid=rss | Opinion: Slower S&P 500 earnings progress isn’t bullish — it doesn’t matter what some inventory market ‘consultants’ are saying


Inter Reviewed is an automatic aggregator of the all world’s media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, all materials to their authors. If you are the owner of the content and do not want us to publish your materials, please contact us by email – admin@interreviewed.com. The content will be deleted within 24 hours.

Related Articles

Back to top button