MLB roundtable: Is Corey Seager or Carlos Correa the best shortstop on the market?

The Atlanta Braves are World Sequence champions and the 2021-22 offseason is formally underway. We have already seen our first notable commerce (Tucker Barnhart to the Tigers), free agent signing (Andrew Heaney to the Dodgers), and waiver declare (Wade Miley to the Cubs) of the winter. There’s heaps extra exercise to come back over the subsequent few months.

All through the offseason the CBS Sports activities MLB scribes will carry you a weekly roundtable breaking down fairly a lot something. The newest information, a historic query, ideas about the way forward for baseball, all types of stuff. In our last roundtable we discussed our favorite moments of the 2021 season. Now to this week’s query.

R.J. Anderson: Correa. Each are good gamers whom any group can be lucky to make use of. However Correa is a greater defensive shortstop, and the higher guess to stay on the place long run. Even should you give Seager the sting offensively (they usually’re shut, numbers-wise), you must then give Correa the sting from a sturdiness standpoint. I completely perceive anybody who desires to carry the sign-stealing scandal in opposition to Correa; in a vacuum, although, I feel he is the superior participant.

Dayn Perry: I would go Correa, and it isn’t an particularly shut name for me. They’re related offensively, however I give Correa an enormous edge on protection on the crucial place of shortstop. Additionally, they have been trending in reverse instructions by way of well being in recent times, and that is to Correa’s profit. 

Matt Snyder: I will take part on the Correa social gathering. Whereas sturdiness was a priority for a whereas with him, he performed 58 of the 60 video games in 2020 after which 148 this yr earlier than one other deep playoff run the place he tacked on 14 extra begins. Given the best way he hit this previous season, his immense upside on the plate and the way he is frequently improved with the glove, he is an elite famous person hitting the market on the actual proper time. Even when somebody had sturdiness issues on Correa and favored Seager’s bat a bit extra — each comprehensible — Seager’s sturdiness issues are a lot higher. After his first two full seasons (and tossing out 2020), Seager has performed in 26, 134 and 95 video games, respectively. 

Mike Axisa: I am making it unanimous and saying Correa. They’re comparable hitters (i.e. each wonderful with big-game chops) and are each solely 27, so that you’re getting peak years with each. Correa is a significantly higher defender although, each in keeping with the attention take a look at and the numbers:

  • Seager (2017-21): plus-3 Defensive Runs Saved and minus-1 Outs Above Common
  • Correa (2017-21): plus-53 Defensive Runs Saved and plus-46 Outs Above Common

Each gamers will deservedly obtain huge contracts, but when I am spending this big on a shortstop, I wish to make certain I really get a shortstop. Seager’s glove is sufficient of a query that he might wind up at third base inside a yr or two, leaving me to once more search for a shortstop. They’re each wonderful gamers — you choose one and I will fortunately take the opposite — however Correa is my choose due to the protection. | MLB roundtable: Is Corey Seager or Carlos Correa the perfect shortstop available on the market?


Inter Reviewed is an automatic aggregator of the all world’s media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, all materials to their authors. If you are the owner of the content and do not want us to publish your materials, please contact us by email – The content will be deleted within 24 hours.

Related Articles

Back to top button