Everybody in some unspecified time in the future realizes that adults aren’t routinely sensible. The identical goes for politicians. In actual fact, they typically declare to know issues they know nothing about. There have been two good examples of this on Tuesday. One got here when an exasperated Dr. Anthony Fauci schooled Senator Rand Paul, who he advised him level clean, concerning the Wuhan “lab leak” conspiracy idea, “you don’t know what you’re speaking about.” The opposite, no shock, got here from Marjorie Taylor Greene.
Scorching off being banned for 12 hours from tweeting because of COVID-19 misinformation, the controversial consultant walked into it once more. Throughout a press convention, a journalist requested Greene — whose try and attraction a $500 wonderful, issued for not sporting a masks within the Home again in Might, was met with failure — the million greenback query: Is she, the truth is, vaccinated. She pleaded the fifth, type of, claiming that was a “a violation of my HIPAA rights.”
Greene was referring to the Well being Insurance coverage Portability and Accountability Act, which protects private info acquired by well being officers, comparable to docs, from fraud and theft. This poses one other query: Does somebody, comparable to a journalist or a possible employer and even the workers at a movie show, asking about one’s vaccination standing violate the HIPAA?
Loads of articles have been revealed within the final handful of months as vaccine skeptics have tried to drift this concept. Here’s one, from no much less a supply than the HIPAA Journal. All have reached the identical conclusion: HIPAA doesn’t defend one from revealing whether or not or not one is a well being risk, together with for the extremely contagious and transmissible COVID-19. The closest such a query would come to an HIPAA violation is that if somebody requested her physician to disclose her standing, which isn’t what occurred at this presser.
Some broke down the way it actually works.
That is in no way how HIPAA works. I can ask you all day lengthy when you’re vaccinated, and you’ll inform me or not. Now when you ask my physician and HE tells you, that is a violation. Supply: I work with PHI all day lengthy. https://t.co/f8IoNGMedO
— It is James and the Terrible Fact (@TweetFiction) July 20, 2021
Think about if the legislation was that you simply aren’t allowed to ask somebody about their very own well being? Or reply questions on your individual well being? That might be insane. Good factor that’s not what HIPAA means. https://t.co/cZuNO2hjAY
— Olivia Messer 🌊 (@OliviaMesser) July 20, 2021
CNN’s crack reality checker Daniel Dale identified Greene has completed this on a number of events but at all times appears to overlook, someway, when she’s been debunked.
Others merely roasted her for the arrogance with which she revealed she has no thought what she’s speaking about.
Asking somebody in the event that they’re vaccinated doesn’t violate their HIPAA rights lmao. The place does she give you these items https://t.co/zrwFz5sMTs
— Laura Bassett (@LEBassett) July 20, 2021
As somebody who needed to take yearly exams on HIPAA rights whereas working at a hospital for 12 years, I can inform all of y’all that that is the truth is NOT a violation of Marge’s HIPAA rights.
Let’s elect leaders that not less than know some fundamentals on how issues in the actual world work. https://t.co/B0t7yRBtL0
— Russell Foster for Texas (@RussellFosterTX) July 20, 2021
This isn’t a violation of HIPAA, which solely applies to docs, nurses, hospitals/clinics, pharmacies, medical health insurance, and many others. Greene does not must reply, however to make use of the declare that asking the query is a violation of HIPAA as an excuse reveals the depths of her ignorance. https://t.co/gixXybwJT0
— David Gorski, MD, PhD (@gorskon) July 20, 2021
There are two rights individuals assume they perceive what they imply, however don’t:
1. First Modification
When these persons are precise elected officers, you understand we’re in bother https://t.co/osM3uQZGkD
— Matt Jones (@KySportsRadio) July 20, 2021
Others learn this as a attainable confession that, sure, she has been vaccinated, which might appall her base.
Marjorie Taylor Greene is sort of definitely vaccinated however doesn’t wish to say so as a result of it has turn out to be taboo amongst Trumpists, which is so extremely damning on each ends.
Additionally, that’s *positively* not what HIPAA is. https://t.co/wPihQ69ASS
— Caroline Orr Bueno, Ph.D (@RVAwonk) July 20, 2021
Greene’s vaccine stubbornness comes at a very awkward time for her get together. A lot of outstanding conservatives, noticing the truth that the overwhelming majority of recent instances and deaths are among the many unvaccinated, have had an about-face, and at the moment are imploring their viewers to get dosed already. That even Sean Hannity is doing extra to save lots of individuals than Marjorie Taylor Greene actually does say one thing.
https://uproxx.com/viral/marjorie-taylor-greene-vaccination-question-hipaa-rights-twitter-reactions/ | Marjorie Taylor Greene Roasted For Not Understanding HIPAA Rights