Is Buster Posey a Hall of Famer? Breaking down the All-Star catcher’s case for the Hall of Fame

Longtime Giants catcher Buster Posey is reportedly planning to announce his retirement Thursday following a 12-year MLB profession which included three World Sequence championships, seven All-Star appearances and the 2012 NL MVP award. When a participant of Posey’s stature retires, the pure dialogue flows towards whether or not or not he is a Corridor of Famer and, hey, I like speaking historical past. Let’s do it. Here is a take a look at Posey’s Corridor of Fame case. 

Fee stats

That is fairly straightforward. He is there. Posey is a profession .302/.372/.460 hitter, which is sweet for a 129 OPS+ and wRC+. That’s, over the course of his profession he was 29 % higher than the common hitter. If he have been a delegated hitter or first baseman, that in all probability would not be ok. 

Since I discussed that, let’s level out that for no matter purpose, there is a small faction of followers who appreciated to name Posey a primary baseman over time as some sort of put down. It is whole nonsense. In his profession, he appeared in 1,093 video games as a catcher, 229 at first and 31 at DH. He is a catcher. 

Now that I’ve established that, Posey’s profession slash line is among the many greatest ever for Corridor-eligible catchers. Amongst gamers with no less than 1,000 video games within the majors who caught no less than 50 % of their video games, he is considered one of simply six to hit over .300 for his profession. He is ninth in on-base share and thirteenth in slugging. OPS+ adjusts for ballpark and period situations and keep in mind that Posey performed his residence video games in a cavernous park. He is third right here behind Mike Piazza and Gene Tenace. Whammy

We will loop in protection, too. In the course of the course of Posey’s profession, the league common for caught stealing price was 27 %. Posey threw out 33 %. 

Counting stats

That is the place the place Posey’s physique of labor might come beneath scrutiny. Between getting simply seven video games in 2009 and 108 in his precise rookie yr, then breaking his leg in 2011 and opting out of the 2020 season, he performed in simply 1,371 video games throughout elements of 12 seasons. As such, he ends with 1,500 hits (good spherical quantity, huh?), 293 doubles, 158 homers, 729 RBI and 663 runs. 

These will appear low to lots of people. 

Given how good he was on a price foundation, although, these rankings amongst catchers aren’t horrible: 

  • Hits: thirty fourth
  • 2B: twenty fifth
  • HR: fortieth
  • RBI: fortieth
  • Runs: fortieth

Once more, think about how good he was on a shortened profession, so sitting high 40 amongst catchers in all these issues is superb. 

Defensively, Posey by no means allowed greater than 5 handed balls in a season and he did this whereas being a tremendous framer (we’ll get to that). He gave up simply 27 handed balls in 9,291 2/3 regular-season innings behind the plate. That is one each 344 innings. For comparability’s sake, Yadier Molina has lengthy been thought-about the gold commonplace defender at catcher. He is given up one handed ball each 186 innings in his profession. 

Full profession, cumulative measurements

With the brief profession, Posey is clearly a peak candidate and never a compiler. That is been established. So let us take a look at his peak. JAWS loops that in and Posey is 14th amongst catchers in historical past, behind 10 Corridor of Famers, Joe Mauer (not but eligible), Thurman Munson and Tenace. He is forward of eight Corridor of Famers (and Molina). WAR7 is the measure of the highest seven WAR seasons (once more, the height) and Posey is tenth behind eight Corridor of Famers, Mauer and Thurman Munson. He is higher than the common Corridor of Fame catcher right here. 

In baseball-reference WAR, Posey ranks sixteenth all-time amongst catchers. He is beneath the common Corridor of Fame catcher, however catcher is fairly under-represented within the Corridor, relative to a number of different positions. 

Additionally, there is a twist right here.’s WAR model does not loop in framing metrics. Fangraphs’ WAR does and Posey was a tremendous framer, stealing strikes for nice Giants pitching staffs for years. Within the Fangraphs model, Posey is eighth all-time amongst catchers, trailing Johnny Bench, Gary Carter, Ivan Rodriguez, Carlton Fisk, Yogi Berra, Piazza and Joe Torre. He is forward of Invoice Dickey, Molina, Ted Simmons, Gabby Hartnett, Mauer and others. 

Additional, utilizing Fangraphs WAR (once more, it consists of his framing worth which was substantial), throughout Posey’s profession — if we lop off the seven video games in 2009 and begin with 2010 — he was the second most precious participant in all of baseball after Mike Trout. For actual, even with the damaged leg season and opting out of 2020, that is the place he ranks. These seasons are included and he is nonetheless second to Trout. 


Posey gained Rookie of the Yr in the identical season that he caught the final out of the primary ever San Francisco Giants World Sequence title. He gained MVP in identical yr he caught the second. He additionally gained a 3rd ring. The Giants went 11-2 in playoff collection (together with two wild card recreation wins) during which he was their major catcher. He is a seven-time All-Star. He gained 4 Silver Sluggers and a Gold Glove. He gained the batting title and led the league in OPS+ in 2012. Except for the win, he had two different top-10 finishes in MVP voting. 


I feel we have established my emotions by now on the topic, however we will shut with this one to convey it residence. 

Is not there a “really feel” part? If you speak about Buster Posey, does not he really feel like a Corridor of Famer? 

He certain does to me. He is a Giants legend with zero off-field points. He is been one of the crucial revered gamers within the recreation for a decade-plus. The one place he may be a bit missing is within the counting stats, however there’s overwhelming proof all over the place else that he belongs. | Is Buster Posey a Corridor of Famer? Breaking down the All-Star catcher’s case for the Corridor of Fame


Inter Reviewed is an automatic aggregator of the all world’s media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, all materials to their authors. If you are the owner of the content and do not want us to publish your materials, please contact us by email – The content will be deleted within 24 hours.

Related Articles

Back to top button