Gardner Minshew trade grades: Eagles and Jaguars get high marks for 53-man roster deadline deal

The Philadelphia Eagles pulled off one of many stunning trades as 53-man roster cutdown day is approaching. Hours after the workforce’s preseason finale vs. the New York Jets, Philadelphia despatched a conditional 2022 sixth-round draft choose to the Jacksonville Jaguars in trade for Gardner Minshew. The choose for Jacksonville can improve to a 2022 fifth-round choose if Minshew performs at the least 50% of the snaps in three video games this season. 

How did the Eagles and Jaguars fare on this deal? Seems each of them achieved their mission because the 53-man roster deadline is approaching. 

Eagles: A 

Watching Philadelphia’s backup quarterback scenario this preseason was abysmal. Joe Flacco did not seem like a match within the offense and Nick Mullens struggled all through the exhibition portion of the schedule. The Eagles could not proceed with Mullens on the roster, because the veteran quarterback did not have the zip on his throws after having elbow surgical procedure earlier this offseason. Mullens seemed if he wanted extra time to get his arm power and fastball again, which is why the Eagles launched him instantly after the Minshew commerce was official. 

Flacco’s future is unsure, regardless of the Eagles giving the previous Super Bowl MVP $3.5 million assured. The veteran seemed to be in line for the Eagles backup quarterback job previous to the Minshew commerce, however the Eagles performed him the whole first half within the preseason finale vs. the Jets — a possible showcase to different groups that want a backup quarterback. Flacco might nonetheless stay on this roster as a No. 3 quarterback, though $3.5 million is some huge cash for a player who could be inactive most Sundays (barring damage). 

Let’s get to Minshew, who needs to be the No. 2 quarterback on this roster. The resume speaks for itself. 

Minshew accomplished 66.1% of his passes final season for two,259 yards with 16 touchdowns to 5 interceptions, ending with a quarterback score of 95.9. He has began 20 video games for the Jaguars over his two NFL seasons, finishing 62.9% of his passes with 37 touchdowns and 11 interceptions (93.1 score). Minshew is twenty fifth within the league in completion proportion, twentieth in touchdowns, and and fourth in interception proportion (1.38) since getting into the league in 2019. His 93.1 passer score is the twelfth highest for a quarterback after their first two seasons (minimal 500 makes an attempt). 

The Eagles gave up a sixth-round choose (doubtlessly a fifth), for a quarterback that may step in if Hurts suffers an damage. Minshew’s talent set matches this offense higher than Flacco and has familiarity with a key member of this entrance workplace. Former Jaguars basic supervisor Dave Caldwell joined the Eagles as a personnel govt this offseason after spending eight years main Jacksonville’s entrance workplace. Caldwell chosen Minshew within the sixth spherical of the 2019 NFL Draft and was instrumental in bringing him to Philadelphia. 

Enhancing the depth within the quarterback room is a mantra of the Eagles below basic supervisor Howie Roseman. They achieved that with the Minshew commerce — a confirmed quarterback that may begin on this league if wanted for a Day 3 choose. 

Jaguars: A-

Jacksonville was by no means going to begin Minshew over Trevor Lawrence, regardless of how head coach City Meyer tried to spin the quarterback competitors this offseason. As soon as Lawrence was formally named the beginning quarterback, Minshew was on the block. The Jaguars additionally signed C.J. Beathard this offseason, who elevates to the No. 2 quarterback function. In addition they have Jake Luton on the roster, so the quarterback room is about. 

This transfer was all about Lawrence, guaranteeing he is the quarterback and will not be wanting over his shoulder (he should not must anyway) in a rookie season the place he’ll discover ways to play within the NFL. The Jaguars are nonetheless rebuilding the roster and wish to see what items match round Lawrence as he performs all 17 video games his rookie season (barring damage). Not having Travis Etienne places a damper on creating Lawrence, however he’ll be rising within the system all through 12 months one. Minshew did his job of offering ample competitors for Lawrence earlier than the formality of the No. 1 total choose getting the beginning job was his. 

Give Jacksonville credit score. They drafted a quarterback within the sixth spherical, developed him, and acquired doubtlessly the next draft choose in return for that quarterback two years later. Of the 41 quarterbacks drafted within the sixth spherical or later since 2010, Minshew has been by far the best outdoors of Tyrod Taylor. Getting any draft compensation for Minshew is a win in broader phrases, however might they’ve landed higher compensation for him in the event that they waited just a few extra days? Did not assist Minshew being on the buying and selling block was recognized across the league and Jacksonville was nonetheless in a position to land a good Day 3 choose for him. 

Jacksonville takes a success at backup quarterback, however Lawrence is the franchise quarterback on a rebuilding workforce. The Jaguars did not want a premium backup quarterback on this roster. | Gardner Minshew commerce grades: Eagles and Jaguars get excessive marks for 53-man roster deadline deal


Inter Reviewed is an automatic aggregator of the all world’s media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, all materials to their authors. If you are the owner of the content and do not want us to publish your materials, please contact us by email – The content will be deleted within 24 hours.

Related Articles

Back to top button