Colin Powell Was Nearly the Future of the GOP Before Donald Trump

Former Secretary of State Colin Powell, who sadly passed away from COVID complications, shall be remembered for a lot of accomplishments and failings. His legacy can have detractors on the precise (he was a sellout who endorsed Obama) and the left (he misled us about WMDs), however I can’t assist pondering what if he had been the way forward for the Republican Occasion?

Counterfactuals are at all times messy, however bear with me. There’s cause to consider that Powell was Ronald Reagan’s imaginative and prescient of the Republican Occasion’s brilliant future. And Powell may nicely have defeated Invoice Clinton in 1996. That might have made Powell America’s first Black president. Assuming re-election, he would have been president when 9/11 occurred. All the things thereafter would, doubtless, have been very completely different.

And, in fact, it’s exhausting to think about a starker distinction than what ultimately occurred to America (and the GOP): President Donald J. Trump.

This really may have occurred. Fourteen months earlier than the 1996 presidential election, a Time/CNN poll found that “If the 1996 presidential election have been held right this moment, Colin Powell, working on the GOP ticket, would beat Invoice Clinton 46 p.c to 38 p.c…”

So why didn’t he run? Powell’s spouse, Alma, most likely was the deciding issue. As Howard Fineman wrote in 1995, “she worries about her husband’s security and cherishes her privateness…” There’s additionally the truth that Powell was, from the beginning, a liberal Republican in a celebration that was transferring rightward. On a variety of points like abortion and affirmative action, Powell was out-of-step with the conservative zeitgeist. Gary Bauer, who was head of the Household Analysis Council, known as him “Bill Clinton with ribbons.”

Nonetheless, Republicans nominated Bob Dole—not somebody like televangelist Pat Robertson or right-wing populist Pat Buchanan—that 12 months. And, in fact, the GOP in the end would find yourself with Donald Trump, whose insurance policies have been simply as liberal as Powell’s, and whose private {and professional} life have been decidedly much less conservative. We will solely marvel what would have occurred if Powell had put every part he had into being the GOP normal bearer, after which the chief of the free world.

This, I consider, was the hope of no much less a conservative icon than Ronald Reagan. Take into account a Larry King interview from 1991 with then-former President Reagan. The Gipper gushed about his “nice admiration of him and a private feeling of friendship” for Powell, who had been his Nationwide Safety Advisor. When requested about future Republican leaders (like Dick Cheney), he demurred.

Later, in 1993, Reagan invited Powell to the Reagan Library in Simi Valley, California, and offered him with an award. “I do know I shouldn’t say this, however I’ve a confession to make. I simply may need had an ulterior motive for inviting Colin Powell up right here right this moment to my presidential library,” Reagan said. “You see, I’m hoping that maybe sooner or later he’ll return the favor and invite me to his.”

Revisionist historical past can’t assume probably the most constructive alternate model. A Powell presidency may need given us a totally completely different form of catastrophe. However as paleoconservative author Jim Antle suggests, the Iraq struggle would doubtless not have occurred: “As commander-in-chief, the choices would have been his. He would have been much less inclined to fall beneath the sway of Cheney and the neoconservatives, in the event that they occupied outstanding roles in his administration in any respect,” Antle writes.


No Iraq struggle most likely means no Obama and no Trump. What’s extra, Invoice Clinton (and America) would have been spared the entire Monica Lewinsky ordeal. As for the GOP, Antle writes, “Bush Republicanism may not have been finest preserved by one other Bush.”

As a substitute of that, Powell watched the celebration slip away from him. In 2014, Powell was requested on Meet the Press about his political affiliation. “I’m nonetheless a Republican,” he said. “And I feel the Republican Occasion wants me greater than the Democratic Occasion wants me.”

By 2021, he said that he may “not name himself a Republican.” In between these years, Donald J. Trump turned the Republican’s normal bearer, after which America’s president.

For many who say Trump was the GOP’s inevitable conclusion, I current President Powell as Exhibit A. Sure, the Grand Outdated Occasion hid a long-dormant poisonous pressure, however it didn’t essentially have to return to a head. It’s a disgrace {that a} chief like Powell didn’t emerge, however in the end, Republicans personal their selections.

Within the run-up to the second Iraq struggle, Powell turned well-known for speaking about his so-called the Pottery Barn rule: You break it, you personal it. Virtually instantly, this slogan turned a verdict on the failed struggle that he helped pave the best way for. However it’s additionally an indictment of Republican voters.

They broke it in 2016. And now, with Trump, they purchased it. way of=rss | Colin Powell Was Practically the Way forward for the GOP Earlier than Donald Trump


Inter Reviewed is an automatic aggregator of the all world’s media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, all materials to their authors. If you are the owner of the content and do not want us to publish your materials, please contact us by email – The content will be deleted within 24 hours.

Related Articles

Back to top button