Candid Coaches: Is Oklahoma and Texas leaving Big 12 for SEC good or bad for college basketball?

CBS Sports activities school basketball writers Gary Parrish and Matt Norlander surveyed greater than 100 coaches for our annual Candid Coaches collection. They polled everybody from head coaches at elite packages to assistants at a number of the smallest Division I colleges. In change for full anonymity, the coaches offered unfiltered honesty about quite a few matters. Over the subsequent couple of weeks, we’ll be posting the outcomes on 10 questions requested.

Oklahoma and Texas agreeing earlier this offseason to go away the Massive 12 for the SEC was a transfer motivated by soccer and cash. Basketball performed principally no function on this spherical of realignment, as is sort of all the time the case. It simply does not matter a lot relating to this stuff. However that does not imply the transfer will not influence basketball in a wide range of methods at a number of ranges. In reality, it already has. So, with that in thoughts, Matt Norlander and I requested greater than 100 school basketball coaches the next query:

Is Oklahoma and Texas leaving the Massive 12 for the SEC good or unhealthy for school basketball?

Unhealthy 64%
Good 22%
Would not actually matter 14%

Quotes that stood out

  • “It is horrendous for school basketball. The built-in rivalries which might be going to be a distant reminiscence are going to harm. All that is performed for soccer — nevertheless it kills our recreation and also you notice how meaningless school basketball is when it comes in keeping with soccer. You are dropping each single time towards soccer. Each time. It reveals the place you’re within the pecking order. When the Massive 12 was going to determine itself or get divided up — each time that occurred a number of years again, when TCU went to the Massive 12 — Kansas was going to be omitted and don’t have any place to go. That is one of many greatest colleges within the historical past of school basketball and nobody cared as a result of it was college football and their soccer crew stinks. Nobody cared about bringing them into their league. That is one thing that basically scares me.”
  • “It isn’t good. Each [the SEC and Big 12] have been extraordinarily aggressive and had nice steadiness. Now one is clearly higher than the opposite.”
  • “To have two of [the Big 12’s] greatest manufacturers go away to go to an already-loaded basketball convention, solely takes away from the parity of our sport. It is simply bizarre, man. It is like when the Massive East colleges left for the ACC, and also you misplaced these geographical rivalries, these historic rivalries. It takes away from one thing that is a part of the material of school basketball.”
  • “[The move caused] the American [to] grow to be Convention USA — which can actually proceed to widen the hole between high-major and mid-major leagues. There might be even much less alternatives for leagues outdoors of the Energy 5 and Massive East to get a number of bids.”
  • “It issues me as a mid-major coach in that I imagine we’re headed to the Autonomy 5 trying to interrupt off.”

The takeaway

You may’ve observed I solely included quotes from coaches who stated Oklahoma and Texas becoming a member of the SEC is unhealthy for school basketball. I did that for 2 causes: 1) Most of the “good” votes got here from SEC coaches. In order that they largely meant “it is good for us” versus “it is good for school basketball.” 2) Actually no one Norlander and I communicated with made a compelling case that the strikes are literally good for school basketball normally. Some non-SEC coaches agreed with the SEC coaches that the strikes have been good for the SEC. Others famous how the strikes have been good for Houston, UCF and Cincinnati as a result of they created a chance for these colleges to exchange Oklahoma and Texas within the Massive 12 and thus enhance their place on this planet of school athletics. However no one actually made a compelling case supporting the concept that Oklahoma and Texas leaving the Massive 12 is definitely good for school basketball normally.

And that is as a result of it is a exhausting case to make.

Let’s begin with the truth that the second the Massive 12 determined to exchange Oklahoma and Texas with Cincinnati, Houston and UCF, the American misplaced two of its finest 4 basketball packages — and maybe three of its finest six relying on the way you wish to energy rank UCF relative to Tulsa, Temple and SMU. Similar to that, school basketball went from having seven sure-bet multi-bid conferences to simply six sure-bet multi-bid conferences. As a number of coaches identified, with out Cincinnati, Houston and UCF, the AAC will possible begin to resemble the outdated Convention USA that Memphis as soon as overwhelmed underneath John Calipari.

Shedding a great convention will not be good for the game.

So along with the lack of regional rivalries, historic matchups and all the different issues convention realignment normally sacrifices within the pursuit of cash, these strikes completely demolished a high quality league. That is the worst half. Positive, the SEC might be enjoyable, I suppose. However the sport is healthier with seven good leagues than it is going to be with solely six good leagues. And, as numerous coaches identified, Oklahoma and Texas leaving the Massive 12, which led to Cincinnati, Houston and UCF leaving the AAC, will solely widen the hole between the haves and have-nots in school athletics and create a scenario the place practically all the at-large bids to the NCAA Tournament will yearly go to packages in a Energy 5 convention or the Massive East.

Good luck to everyone else.

They will want it.

Beforehand in Candid Coaches: | Candid Coaches: Is Oklahoma and Texas leaving Massive 12 for SEC good or unhealthy for school basketball?


Inter Reviewed is an automatic aggregator of the all world’s media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, all materials to their authors. If you are the owner of the content and do not want us to publish your materials, please contact us by email – The content will be deleted within 24 hours.

Related Articles

Back to top button