ATA, Freight Stakeholders Push Back on US Senate’s PRO Act

[Stay on top of transportation news: Get TTNews in your inbox.]

Freight stakeholders are voicing opposition to a invoice presently being debated within the U.S. Senate that goals to make modifications to federal classification for staff.

American Trucking Associations and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce are amongst these countering provisions within the Defending the Proper to Set up, or PRO, Act, which — amongst different issues — would revise the federal definitions of an worker, supervisor and employer.

“The federal government ought to respect and assist the Individuals who select to develop into owner-operators within the trucking trade. Conversely, the federal government shouldn’t power these Individuals out of enterprise by insisting on the authoritarian view that worker standing is best for them,” stated Edwin Gilroy, ATA’s senior vp of legislative affairs, in a letter to the Senate Well being, Training, Labor, and Pensions Committee. He emphasised the invoice has the potential to jeopardize the livelihoods of lots of of 1000’s of owner-operators within the trucking trade, destabilizing provide chains and irreparably harming the nationwide economic system.

PROACT by Transport Topics on Scribd

The invoice would outline an organization because the employer in circumstances the place a franchisor is decided to be exerting substantial administration within the office. The laws additionally would broaden efforts linked to collective bargaining within the office. Within the evenly divided Senate, the laws presently is wanting the requisite votes for approval. The U.S. Home of Representatives accredited a model of the invoice earlier this yr.

Edwin Gilroy


ATA additionally questions the invoice’s concentrate on the “ABC take a look at,” which determines if a driver is an worker or a contractor via particular standards, together with if the person works outdoors the corporate’s typical line of operations.

“The ‘ABC take a look at’ successfully bans most impartial owner-operators from working within the trucking trade, destroying the livelihoods of over 350,000 small enterprise entrepreneurs and needlessly gutting the nation’s already fragile provide chain of its frontline important staff,” Gilroy stated.

Sean Redmond, government director for labor coverage on the U.S. Chamber, added, “There are nonetheless extra elements of the PRO Act that don’t take pleasure in public assist, such because the invoice’s undermining of impartial contractors by deeming them to be staff for unionizing functions and its menace to the franchise enterprise mannequin.”

Sen. Bill Cassidy

Louisiana Republican Sen. Invoice Cassidy (Stefani Reynolds/The New York Instances/Bloomberg Information)

Throughout a Well being, Training, Labor, and Pensions committee listening to July 22, panel member Sen. Invoice Cassidy (R-La.), additionally pushed again on the measure.

“Rigid work guidelines created a cost-disadvantage over factories, manufacturing vegetation that have been positioned abroad,” he stated. “You may make the case that proper to work legal guidelines really created the chance for manufacturing to stay in the USA as a result of it’s not simply the wage, additionally it is the inflexibility of labor guidelines that make it troublesome.”

Throughout that listening to, Jyoti Sarolia, principal and managing associate at California-based Ellis Hospitality, added, “If the PRO Act turns into legislation, franchise manufacturers will react by providing fewer franchises, and consequently, individuals like me shall be collateral injury. Upending a complete enterprise mannequin and taking away enterprise alternatives to individuals like me, simply to extend union energy, is unacceptable.”

Stronger organizing and collective bargaining rights may have helped change the trajectory of this pandemic and saved lives by making certain office security was a precedence.

Sen. Patty Murray,  Well being, Training, Labor, and Pensions chairwoman 

Sen. Patty Murray

Senate Democrats, nevertheless, sought to hyperlink union membership with higher pay for girls and minority staff.

“Stronger organizing and collective bargaining rights may have helped change the trajectory of this pandemic and saved lives by making certain office security was a precedence, extra staff had paid sick days, and extra staff had the wages and advantages they wanted to remain economically safe, like high quality, inexpensive well being care, and a dependable retirement plan,” stated Well being, Training, Labor, and Pensions Chairwoman Patty Murray (D-Wash.), sponsor of the laws.

Proponents of the invoice embody the AFL-CIO, which backed the Home model. The group’s president, Richard Trumka, lately said, “Our members and all working persons are dedicated to creating the PRO Act the legislation of the land this yr.”

Sarolia cautioned towards portray all staff with a broad brush.

“Put merely, companies don’t react in a vacuum,” he stated.

Need extra information? Take heed to as we speak’s each day briefing beneath or go here for more info: | ATA, Freight Stakeholders Push Again on US Senate’s PRO Act


Inter Reviewed is an automatic aggregator of the all world’s media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, all materials to their authors. If you are the owner of the content and do not want us to publish your materials, please contact us by email – The content will be deleted within 24 hours.

Related Articles

Back to top button