Childhood is a time to figure out who you are, what you like, and how you want to present yourself to the world — and sometimes, that process also leads to behavior that, in hindsight, can shameful or reprehensible. Investigating those experiences to understand what they say about us — then and now — can be an unpleasant undertaking. That is exactly the mission made by When we were bulliesThe Oscar-nominated short documentary by acclaimed filmmaker Jay Rosenblatt tells the story of a traumatic incident in his past, the memories it evokes, and the lessons he learns about it. the target of bad behavior, his classmates and himself.
Premiering March 30 on HBO, When we were bullies is Rosenblatt’s journey back in time — specifically to his 1965-1966 fifth grade year at PS 194 in Brooklyn, New York. That’s not the only era the film revisits, though, as Rosenblatt begins her 35-minute gem with today’s shot of him and another man struggling to climb over the line. fence and enter the schoolyard of PS 194, where, decades ago, they abused a fellow student. Before Rosenblatt could fully grasp that fateful day, he detailed the origins of this self-examination, which began in 1992 in San Francisco. Working on what would become his brief 1994 The smell of ant stingsRosenblatt was scanning scenes from 1950s black and white educational films when his eyes were caught by a clip of two kids fighting in front of an elementary school — and specifically, by a brief example in which a The kid suddenly passing by this feat threw a quick punch at one of the boxers.
The reason this fleeting moment made Rosenblatt so impressive is that he saw himself in this “collaborator,” due to his own teenage misdeeds. However, to explain that forming event, Rosenblatt must first recount an amazing coincidence. In 1994, while teaching a course on filmmaking, he was impressed by the narrator of a student project, and approached this person. Incredibly, it was Richard, a 5th grade classmate of Rosenblatt’s, whose memory is still sharp about their bullying incidents. On another normal Wednesday, their teacher, Mrs. Bromberg, held the class late, blaming “Richard” for speaking when he should have been silent. Since Richard knew he was not responsible, he quickly surmised that Mrs. Bromberg was referring to their classmate as Dick (the nickname the boy had received in fourth grade, because he lived with him). room with three other Richards). Richard tells everyone that Dick has received their punishment, and when the bell rings, many students chase Dick, surrounding him on the playground and beating him until he can finally run away.
“There’s also Erik Ian Walker’s Schubert-inspired soundtrack with sparkling strings, guitars and timbres, which is a subtle moving aesthetic that captures the intimate feeling of the period in question, also like Rosenblatt’s strong connection to this story.”
Rosenblatt never forgot that, the next day, Mrs. Bromberg told the class (except Dick) that they were “animals”, and When we were bullies pinpointing how his guilt and shame persisted over the decades, recurring frequently, like in 1994 when The smell of ant stings release. Follow a Weekly SF In an article about his career that covered his latest event (and this 5th grade incident in turn), Rosenblatt heard from Dick, now a successful television producer, who was very curious. curious to see The smell of ant stings. Rosenblatt sent him a copy and never received a response. Sixteen years later, spurred on by his PS 194th 50th anniversary, Rosenblatt decided to ask every classmate he could follow about their recollection of this bullying incident, and the answer. Their emotions are immediately diverse, sympathetic, and self-critical, mixed with grief and regret that Rosenblatt herself knows well.
When we were bullies is a candid confrontation with an old wound that has never healed, and its candor – and that of Rosenblatt – is cementing. Recounted by the director, it includes not only traditional non-fiction material (interviews, on-site footage) but also clips from 1950s archival films and animated sequences (by Jeremy Rourke), in which images appear on screen like notebooks and childhood portraits of class are cut out of larger pictures and brought to life whispering, twirling. There’s also Erik Ian Walker’s Schubert-inspired soundtrack with sparkling strings, guitars and timbres, which is a subtle moving aesthetic that captures the intimate feeling of the period in question, also like Rosenblatt’s strong connection to this story. A subsequent visit with the now 92-year-old Mrs Bromberg further underscores the personal nature of the filmmaker’s mission, as does Ms Bromberg’s inability to recall this instance of bullying repeating vague memories and/or non-existence of some of Rosenblatt’s grown-up classmates.
When it’s over When we were bullies, Rosenblatt says that convention required him to run away from Dick in order to articulate both his attitude towards the skirmish, and its effect on his life — and, perhaps, to spare excuses for everyone for their misbehavior, which could simply be excitement for kids who are kids. . Instead, however, Rosenblatt says that what viewers are sure to gather is similar: When we were bullies not about Dick at all; rather, it’s about Rosenblatt and his countrymen, and the terrible thing they did when they were young, their prolonged torture, and how those feelings never completely went away. . As someone who lost his brother in 4th grade, Rosenblatt empathizes with his latest sentiments about emotional suffering, and the time people have to hide their wounds to become a soldier. after that.
The consequence is, When we were bullies does not end with a celebratory abandonment but is more moving, with an expression of grief and understanding for the pain Rosenblatt and others have caused, the anguish they all have to endure (in their own way) their pain), and the pain never goes away entirely — for the worse and, maybe, if they show us another, more compassionate path forward, also better.
https://www.thedailybeast.com/a-childhood-bully-vies-for-an-oscar-and-reckons-with-his-past-in-hbos-when-we-were-bullies?source=articles&via=rss A childhood bully wins an Oscar and recounts his past in HBO’s ‘When We Were Bullies’